LAKEWOOD, NJ — The Lakewood Police Department has announced the arrest of William Cottrell, 41, of Toms River, following an investigation into the theft of a boat engine from a marina on Lake Carasaljo.
On April 23, 2026, officers responded to Traveling Tykes Marina for a report of a theft involving a Mercury boat engine that had been removed from a vessel owned by the marina.
Detectives conducted an investigation utilizing various investigative techniques, which ultimately led to the identification of Cottrell as the suspect involved.
On May 19, 2026, Cottrell was charged with burglary and theft related offenses and was later taken into custody without incident.
Chief Gregory H. Meyer praised the efforts of the officers and detectives involved in the case.
“This investigation is a great example of the persistence and teamwork displayed by our officers and detectives,” Meyer said.
“Their efforts, along with the assistance of our law enforcement partners, helped bring this case to a successful conclusion.”
The investigation was conducted by the Lakewood Police Department with assistance from the Ocean County Sheriff’s Office, Seaside Heights Police Department, Toms River Police Department, and Lakewood Shomrim.
The investigation remains ongoing.
